Now Playing
Episode 160
w/host Ezra McCarthy

😬 You know the customer. As soon as their name pops up on your phone, your stomach drops. In this short episode, Ezra and Wena make the case for firing your worst customer, even when the account pays well. After all, revenue is not profit. In fact, some accounts drain your crew, your headspace, and your margins more than they give back.
First, sort your full customer list into A, B, and C accounts. Then make a plan to cut the C’s by next season. For example, watch for scope that creeps every time you pull into the driveway. Other accounts pay late, or their price has not moved in years. Some sit outside your routes, while others complain every visit and yell at your crew.
Still, some accounts can be saved with a conversation or a price increase letter. However, if the problem is character, it is time to go. When you fire a lawn care customer, time it to the end of the season or a contract renewal. Keep the message short, thank them, and then refer them to another company. Also, don’t let the fear of one bad review stop you. For the other side of this, hear how to attract ideal lawn care customers and why lawn care route density matters for profit.
Ezra McCarthy
Hello and welcome back to Lawn Care Blueprint. Today we’re gonna be talking about firing your customers. You know that customer on your route, that landscape job that you thought about quoting? Every time you think about it, your stomach kind of churns a little bit. When they call, your heart rate on your Apple Watch spikes, and 911 is almost called. Okay, not literally, but you know what I’m saying. Whether or not they’re their highest paid customer or not, we’ve all had this experience. And I want to just give you a little encouragement today to fire your worst customer.
So, Wena is with us today. We’ll be doing a short and sweet episode as maybe a top of mind for us here.
Wena
Hello Ezra, so isn’t every customer a good customer when you’re trying to grow? Why would you ever fire one? Is this one based on experience? Have you ever had one?
Ezra McCarthy
Sadly, yes. So we probably all remember we get started, we’re taking every job, doing anything for however much money. But once you get started, and honestly, even from the beginning, I think picking the right customer is almost half of the battle because revenue or gross revenue is not profit. Some accounts pay and some might even be said to cost money.
I remember several years back, I was trying to learn how to grow in all these things, and this business coach that I was learning from said, have A, B and C customers. A-customers are the right job, easy to work with, and have their own nonprofit. B customers are not quite as good, and C are the ones that are a pain, don’t make very much money, and there’s stress.
I would encourage you right now to go through your whole customer list, categorize it as A, B, and C, and then literally cut all of your C or work towards that in the next year. Right now we’re gonna be releasing this here in September and think about next year and say, next year, I don’t want any C customers.
And you may describe, okay, what is the worst customer that you might need to fire? Is it just being difficult? Not necessarily. It may be profitable, but drains you mentally. It may drain your profit and be a pain to work with. It may be underpriced. All these things. Maybe it’s one who stands there in the driveway and they have the scope creep and they want this. And then, while you’re here, this won’t take very long. Or maybe they’re slow to pay. All of these things that are just an absolute pain to deal with.
Maybe you look to yourself and say, hey, you know what? Maybe I am making money, maybe I’m not, but it’s just not worth it for my business. It’s not worth it for my team members, or for my staff. We’re gonna let go.
Wena
And how common is this? Does every lawn company have them?
Ezra McCarthy
Honestly, I think it’s common in every single business, in every single industry. There’s a rule called the 80/20 rule. It could be applied to an insane amount of things. And I think in a lawn care business, it could apply as well. Most of our customers are amazing. But there’s always a small cohort that somehow managed to sneak in that we thought they’d be a good customer and they’re just not.
Maybe they got signed up years ago and they were a good client and now they’re not. So what do we do? Maybe it’s some red flags. Maybe they were priced years ago and we never raised them. Maybe now they’re not in our current routes. They’re farther out than they should be. Maybe it’s scope creep. Maybe they want to skip weeks when it’s not growing as fast as they think it should.
Maybe it’s on the relationship side. Maybe they complain every single visit. Maybe nothing is ever right. Maybe they yell at your crew. Maybe they threaten to leave a review for whatever reason. Maybe they’re constantly negotiating, saying, hey, could we get a cut? Could we get a discount? Maybe they call and text at all hours over the smallest thing. Whatever it might be.
Wena
What about change of ownership? Does it ever happen?
Ezra McCarthy
That could be too. Something changes and they’re not a good fit anymore. What do we do then? We can look at that and say, hey, our business needs the revenue. But what if it’s costing you the headspace that’s losing you a high quality job that you could have? And maybe that bad customer is costing you more than money. Maybe it’s crew morale. Maybe it’s headspace, opportunity cost, maybe it’s quality, whatever these things, what can we do?
Wena
And they’d give you a one star review even if you did a good job. That’s real pain.
Ezra McCarthy
Those happen.
Wena
Yeah, I’ve heard. Can you fix a bad customer before you fire them? Like is there something you can do?
Ezra McCarthy
Yeah, I think there’s sometimes customers that are worth just having a conversation with and maybe just reset the expectations. Sometimes it’s as simple as sending a price increase letter and charging what that job is actually worth. Reset expectations, maybe in scope, how you communicate. And sometimes that’s as simple as what can turn a bad customer into a decent customer. Maybe they didn’t understand, didn’t realize, and sometimes that price increase letter will solve the problem for you as they realize, you know what, we’re not a good fit, and they find someone else.
So sometimes there’s a difference or you have to decide between fixing and firing them. You can fix the problem if it’s unclear scope or pricing, but if the problem is character, they’re dishonest, they’re threatening you with the bad reviews, all these things, that’s when you know it’s time just to let them go.
So what is the right time to let someone go? There’s some good natural breaks at the end of the season, contract renewal, or at your price review. I’d recommend don’t just drop them mid-service and just ghost them. Finish the commitment if you can. Or refer them away. This is my preferred method.
There’s been those that comes new year. I’ve just emailed them or texted them and said, hey, I don’t think we’re a good fit. I’d recommend this business over here that might be able to serve you. Keep it short. Don’t write a long explanation. Don’t criticize them, even if they were wrong. Don’t list all the grievances. Don’t have a twenty-page essay on all the things that they did. Thank them for their business and refer them away. This could be a call, a text, an email. Keep it simple. Don’t overthink it. Just send it to them. And refer them to a competitor. It doesn’t have to be complicated.
You may be saying, well, what if they leave me a bad review? Well, they might. But what I found is sometimes people stress about this too much. If you’re consistently collecting positive reviews, even if you had one out of every thirty, forty, fifty, as long as there’s not a pattern, because that’s what people look for. When I read reviews, I realize that there’s always Karens in every business. You can’t please everyone. If every five out of ten is, hey, this hotel has roaches, this hotel has bad customer service, I’m loaded somewhere else.
But if there’s one out of every hundred, one out of every thirty, I realize, hey, you know what? This is probably a Karen. And most people, unless you really make a mistake, are not gonna go and leave a bad review for a small business. And so don’t allow that to be a reason why you don’t cut these bad customer fits off and refer them away.
Wena
So what do you do with the time and the route space you just freed up after firing that customer?
Ezra McCarthy
You know what I found is as you begin to refine your route, you’re gonna have more opportunity, more headspace to look for service and do a better job for high quality fits. And you’ll be surprised how you fill up that route, how you fill up that job board really quickly.
Wena
They say prevention is better than cure, so how do you keep bad customers from getting in the door in the first place?
Ezra McCarthy
Well, be sure to screen on the phone. Ask them qualifying questions like location, price sensitivity, and things like that. Be sure to be clear in your communication on what to expect and you’d be surprised at how a lot of these things just start to take care of themselves.
Wena
And if someone only does one thing from this episode, what should it be?
Ezra McCarthy
I’d recommend going through all of your customers and as I mentioned, label them A, B, and C customers, and then make an action plan to get rid of every single one of those C customers. If not this week, then look towards next year in the spring rush and say, hey, I’m gonna replace all these C customers with high quality A customers. That when they call, I look forward to answering the phone because if not, what are we in business for anyway, but to have time freedom and financial freedom and work from there.
Well, thank you, each one, for listening. This is a short, sweet, hopefully helpful episode, and we’ll catch you on the next one.
