Now Playing

Episode 113

Lawn Care Blueprint w/ John Pajak: Break Out of the Messy Middle and Scale Your Lawn Business

Ezra McCarthy w/John Pajak

Lawn Care Blueprint podcast artwork

Subscribe and tune in weekly

John Pajak

The lawn care messy middle is a growth stage where many lawn care companies struggle to scale profitably, and John Pajak has spent years helping owners overcome it. As the founder of Turf Tamers and a respected coach in the green industry, he brings more than two decades of real world experience to the conversation. In this episode, he opens up about the hard lessons behind building a second business after his first one failed, and why so many owners get trapped in the lawn care messy middle. His perspective is grounded, practical, and especially relevant for operators trying to move from survival mode into a more stable and profitable company. John does not just talk theory. He speaks from years of trial, error, and hands on work in fertilization, weed control, mowing, and business development.

What makes John especially valuable in this episode is his clear message about focus. He explains that many companies stay stuck in the lawn care messy middle because they try to do too many services before they have even mastered one. Instead of chasing everything, he encourages owners to simplify, specialize, and build a stronger brand around what they do best. That same mindset applies online too, whether you are improving your visibility with organic search improvements, upgrading your digital presence through custom contractor website design, or learning how to use better keyword targeting on your site. For companies trying to get traction, resources on bringing in more lawn care leads and building stronger service pages for growth fit naturally with the lessons John shares.

Another reason this episode stands out is how honestly John talks about the lawn care messy middle as a real growth stage, not just a passing frustration. He describes how businesses in the $150K to $800K range often hit a growth plateau where old habits stop working and new systems are needed to move forward. That includes better positioning, better mentoring, and clearer communication with customers. In a crowded market, he believes that differentiation matters more than ever, and that growth comes when owners stop blending in. These ideas are often expanded on in his Profits with Pajak podcast, where he shares deeper insights on pricing, operations, and business growth. Alongside that, strategies like paid traffic for service businesses, a smarter long term growth plan for lawn companies, and tracking real marketing performance can reinforce the same next step he talks about in this episode.

At the core of John’s message is a simple truth. Most people do not stay stuck because they lack effort. They stay stuck because they lack clarity, focus, and the right guide. That is the real challenge of the lawn care messy middle, and it is also why this episode is so useful for owners who feel like they are spinning their wheels. Whether you call it a growth plateau, a scaling bottleneck, or an awkward stage between startup and maturity, John offers a realistic path forward. He also highlights why tools like AI visibility for lawn care companies are becoming more important as competition increases. Everything he shares in this episode points back to building a business that is more focused, more scalable, and easier to grow over time.

Why Most Lawn Care Businesses Stay Stuck in the ‘Messy Middle’ | John Pajak

🧱 Why do so many lawn care businesses get stuck around $300K-$700K and never break through? John Pajak shares hard-earned lessons from building Turf Tamers and overcoming business failure, focus challenges, and growth plateaus. We dive into why doing too much holds you back, how to differentiate in a crowded market, and what it really takes to move past the lawn care messy middle into a more scalable, profitable business.

Transcript

Ezra McCarthy

Hello and welcome back to Lawn Care Blueprint. Today I have with me John Pajak and we’re going to be discussing his business. We’re going to be talking about some offers that he has for you. He is the founder of Turf Tamers, a fertilization and weed control company there in the Indiana area. He’s known for his tremendous acumen. How do you like how I threw in that word about numbers and also business coaching? John, glad to have you here today.

 

John Pajak

Hey Ezra, happy to be here again. Turf Tamer Lawn Care. Technically this is our 10th season. We started in 2015. Our first full season was 2016. So yeah, it’s kind of crazy how fast time flies. And ever since that happened, all the lessons that I’ve learned, all the things that I’ve experienced over the years, I’ve been in this industry for over 25 years now. And there’s been a lot of people that I just try to help.

As much as possible to guide them. Hopefully they avoid a lot of the mistakes that I’ve encountered and some of the mistakes that others that I know have encountered. Basically all the blood, tears and years that we have suffered, try to shortcut, make shortcuts for people so that they can be successful as soon as possible.

 

Ezra McCarthy

You know, there’s a good quote, John, you just maybe think of there. It says something to the effect of people overestimate what they can get done in one year and underestimate what they can get done in 10. And you just mentioned your latest iteration for the past 10 years, you’ve been doing Turf Tamers Lawn Care. What are some lessons perhaps over the past 10 years that you’ve learned and maybe some lessons you feel like you keep learning?

 

John Pajak

There’s so many, but I feel that if you, depending on what level you’re at, there’s a lot of lessons you could learn. If you’re just starting out, I wouldn’t set out trying to conquer the world in a sense. I would try to, for example, when we started, this is my second lawn care business. The first one had failed. I came back ready to redeem myself in a way. I didn’t want to be, I didn’t want to have that L on my record of failing my first lawn care business.

So when I came back, I’m like okay we’re going to do mowing, we’re going to do landscape, landscape design, we’re going to do hardscaping, we’re going to have fertilization weed control, we’re going to do all these services. And as I started out, I was kind of shotgunned everywhere. I was like I’m going to do all of it. And I realized very very quickly, literally within like two three months of the very first season, I was like this is not working. We have to focus on one thing because we’re not good at anything right now.

We don’t have anything really dialed in. We’ve very quickly pivoted back into we’re just going to mow and that’s how we’re going to start. And for those that are doing this, that’s what I would recommend. I know you have to do it when you’re first starting out. Sometimes it feels like you have to do everything and anything just to get some traction. But really, if you’re starting out, focus on one service, get really good at it, get known for it, and then move to another service.

Nobody’s gonna get mad at you. Just for example, even when we were still just a mowing company, we would have people reaching out and they’re like I got an old garage that needs to be torn down. Can you guys do that? It’s like no, our name, we’re Turf Tamer Lawn Care. We’re not Jim’s handyman or something like that. Why would you call a lawn care company to remove your old one?

The guy wanted his foundation broken up and thought we would be able to cart it off for him. I’m like…

 

Ezra McCarthy

You know what’s interesting? My nephew was a handyman. And one thing that I noticed is the more specific you got, the more you could position yourself as an expert and charge higher. Because maybe think about when you’re talking about a handyman there. When I think of a handyman, I think of someone who can do just a smattering of this or that. If you try to go in as a premium provider of anything and target yourself, sometimes I see people, I was just talking to someone the other day and they were talking about all the services on there.

They’re like yeah we do power washing, we do this, we do lawn care, we do that. And I’m thinking to myself there’s no way that just like you mentioned you’re that great at many of them. So I’m curious, what was your pivoting now you actually pivoted out of lawn care? Did you know how to do fertilization and weed control when you first started the Turf Tamers or is that something that you learned along the way?

 

John Pajak

When I started Turf Tamer, I had experience with it. The company I had worked for in the past was, they were licensed and they showed me the bare minimum of what to do. And we were just basically spreading granular fertilizer for that company. So that part was relatively easy knowing how to calibrate a machine. So that it was only putting out X amount of product. Because it was funny, my boss is like don’t touch the dials on this. Do not mess with the settings.

I was like okay. He was six foot three and had a very long gait. I am, I don’t even know, five eight, five seven, five eight. I don’t know. Maybe I’m a perfect M, five nine. But the thing is it doesn’t really matter how tall I am. I have short legs and my stride is not as long as his. So we were sitting there and we were practicing. He’s like you’re running out of material. And I’m like I didn’t touch anything.

And then I watch him walk with it and this guy is walking almost two times the speed. And it was kind of funny. And I’m like we have to calibrate it to me, not you. Anyway, yes, before going in the 90 early 2000s when I worked for him, that’s when that’s actually when I had my first business and failed. But I thought I had that delusion of well if he’s doing it and I really need money then I could start my own and I could make the money he’s making. And then I could pay off my medical debts and then.

And then I’ll be free and I don’t have to go to bed crying every night. I made that mistake of being a. At that time I wasn’t even like a great technician. I was just an okay technician. But I had the idea that if I could do the work then I could also run the business. And that I failed. And that’s not exactly true. Just because you could do the work doesn’t mean you can run it. But I had a little bit of experience with fertilization weed control back then. Starting out again when Turf Tamer arose from the ashes of my defeat.

I basically made it a mission to learn as much as possible and to be more experienced with it before I even offered it as a service. It’s not exactly a, I wouldn’t recommend being the first thing you do unless you already have experience. Find a mentor. But you know what I mean. If you’re going into it thinking this will be my first venture and I’m going to be all right at it and everything, I would highly recommend that it is possible, but you’re not going to understand a lot of things and you’re.

Probably going to mess up a lot. And it can be very costly if you either go to YouTube University and try to do this on your own. I would highly recommend having a mentor that you actually follow or go work for another company, a reputable one that does fertilization weed control so you understand what you’re really getting yourself into because it’s not hard to accidentally mix the wrong thing and then nuke.

Not only one lawn, but every lawn on your route.

 

Ezra McCarthy

Have you nuked one before, John? I’ve gotta know.

 

John Pajak

I have not. I wouldn’t say I’ve completely nuked one, but I have done some damage. It wasn’t. And this is actually once I was experienced. I used a product called Mesotrione. Tenacity is the common name for it. And I had that mixed into a tank where I was treating a brand new reseeded lawn that we had just renovated. And it works kind of like a pre-emergency. It is a pre-emergent but it’s safe for when you seed.

 

Ezra McCarthy

Right.

 

John Pajak

Well anyway I had leftover in my tank and I was like I have enough for this property that I’ll just go ahead and spray this on there. And I kind of didn’t think about it, but she has a lot of mixed grass in her lawn. We got cool season grasses, Kentucky bluegrass and turf type tall fescue, but she also had some chewings fescues and it’s just some of the grasses that I forgot were more affected by Tenacity. So after I sprayed it out I didn’t think about it and.

One of the side effects of that particular chemical is that it bleaches out the tips of the grass a little bit. So it literally turns white. Not the whole thing turns white. It shouldn’t. Kentucky bluegrass and turf type tall fescue might get a little almost like a bronzing effect where it turns white. But she had creeping bentgrass in her lawn too and I forgot about the effects. It looked like I killed her lawn. There are these huge blotches of brown grass and it didn’t kill it but it dinged it.

And she calls. She’s like hey all the neighbors are wondering what happened. And I’m like what are you talking about? I pull up and I’m like oh no. I could still see some grass was white. That’s a telltale sign. Yeah I was spraying a mix that I used somewhere else. And she was very understanding and I fixed it. So I never at that point, this is just a couple of years ago actually, I had never used a grass dye before. And I purposely bought it just for that job. She liked her.

Properties rather large. Like 34,000 square feet. So it’s not like we’re still under an acre. But she literally has probably three quarters of an acre of turf in her front lawn. So I walked out there with a sprayer. I sprayed that whole thing by hand with the dye and it was like an instant fix. I never painted a lawn before, but I guess I could say I did it now. And it was very.

Humbling experience because you think you know everything and you’re like yeah I’m okay I’ve been doing this for years. And then the next thing you know you make a lawn look kind of. And you’re like my ego, my reputation. Good news is that the lawn bounced back very well even with the dye and it still looks amazing to this day. But it’s.

That was definitely not a fun lesson to learn.

 

Ezra McCarthy

Yeah, so I want to circle back to something we talked about or you mentioned. So you mentioned it’s important getting into business to have a mentor and I couldn’t agree more. And something I think you’re starting here, March, if I remember correctly, you have some coaching groups for fertilization and weed control businesses, or I may have the details. Do you mind filling us in? Who is that for? And then how would it help them? Yeah.

 

John Pajak

It’s really meant for, it’s not just specific to fertilization weed control. It’s really lawn care operators, landscape operators that are in the green industry. That basically if you’re doing anywhere between like 150 to say 800,000 somewhere in that area, maybe just under a million here, but you feel stuck. You’re spinning your wheels. If you’re like that part, that’s where we like to. I kind of call it the messy middle. I’ve been there.

And it’s rough because what works in the beginning isn’t what gets you to the next level per se. And the funny thing is a lot of times when you get to the right, about like 700K, I don’t know why that is like an actual number that once you start approaching that you hit different challenges. And it’s usually because the ones, especially guys that are in maintenance. When I mean maintenance it means like mowing.

Bush trimming services, fertilization weed control. It’s the recurring maintenance. It starts to get really kind of hairy once you hit that area. And a lot of times too before you can even get there, guys just feel like they’re spinning their wheels. They want to start another truck or they want to hire people because they see the potential in their areas and they’re like man I could.

Actually step out of the field and still make good money and have other people working with us instead of it being like a one man show or a one truck show and you’re constantly in that vehicle working and working. So anyway this is mainly like, I wouldn’t say it’s a crash course, but it’s a very guided 10 week program that I’ve put together. And it’s not just me telling you hey do this this and this. I’ll walk hand in hand with you. And it’s only. I can’t do. It’s not open to like a hundred people. It’s not open to 50 people.

I’m trying to just do a small group of individuals that are focused on improving their business. So at this point I’m just looking to fill up maybe basically like 10 seats of people that are motivated to make a change in their business and get over the humps and get some traction where they’re just basically spinning their tires.

 

Ezra McCarthy

What I’ve found personally is groups like this. I know personally I’ve looked in my business. Obviously it’s a little bit different with the marketing space. But I looked and I’ve looked high and low until finally I recently actually just created a mastermind myself because it was either people that were not where I was trying to go or they were just kind of getting started. And I think in our industry as well, getting around people who have been where we want to go or can help us get there is really a cheat code. Have you read the book Story Brand by Donald Miller, by the way, John?

Yep. Yes. I love the framework he uses talking about a guide that basically helps you get there. And he uses some interesting analogies. And I think in our business finding that guide can be helpful. And whether that’s John or someone else in our industry I think it’s definitely worth looking into to really help accelerate your business growth.

 

John Pajak

One of the biggest takeaways from Donald Miller is confuse you lose. If you confuse you lose, meaning it’s not easy to do business with you. Or if the message that you’re trying to send out is confusing, well you’re going to lose. And that is so true. Especially a lot of times when we’re just to stay in the marketing space of lawn care.

It’s kind of sad because a lot of people look like everybody else. It’s like what’s the difference between Turf Tamer and this guy or Turf Tamer and Turf Cutter? What’s the difference? Just the name. They do the same thing. We don’t do mowing anymore, but the thing is if you are out there and you’re marketing and you’re just basically giving them a postcard that lists everything that you do, or your website is literally just listing what you do, you’re not going to stand out.

You have to. And you don’t know that when you first start out.

You understand that as time goes by you kind of have to stand out from the crowd because we are in a very crowded space. If you look at the barrier of entry to say mowing it’s very low. You can be competing with someone that doesn’t really matter. People don’t care what equipment you use for the most part. They’re not interested in the $20,000 mower that you’ve got with all the top of the line trimmers and blowers and all this. My blower blows a thousand cubic feet per minute.

Care about that. They’re concerned about the end result. Does my lawn look good? So if you’re there saying hey we use all this stuff they’re like we don’t care. Well Joey over here he cuts my lawn too. And he only uses a 21 inch mower, a handheld blower and a spin trimmer he found in this back alley that he got working again. But somehow we could be a really high end company that’s competing with the guy next door that has minimal stuff put into it. But all of sudden we are competing with him.

 

Ezra McCarthy

One thing I noticed as well. I wish I could get all of the people that I work with to get professional photography done. Because what I’ve been noticing is all of the people that we work with that have no photos, which I get. If you don’t we’ll work with you and try to help you. But it’s best. We’ve done work for people and they’ve got that professional photography and it’s remarkable how low cost it really is. You can get someone local for five hundred bucks, two thousand dollars. That may sound like a lot but what you’re talking about John is differentiation.

Premium positioning. When people go on the website, well one you need to rank high, but then when they go what do you look like? You put on some and it looks like Mickey Mouse. That’s maybe the best description of it. And just clear imaging along with obviously any good copy too and SEO structure et cetera. But that good imaging can really be the difference between that large commercial contract or the high quality residential customer and someone just taking a 21 inch mower out of the back of their truck.

That should not be our competition.

 

John Pajak

Right. Part of the reason why I kind of pivoted out of mowing. We don’t do mowing services. We haven’t offered them for several years now. But beyond that it’s still. I agree it is important to represent yourself well. Even if you’re just. I mean maybe you’re not day one. Maybe you’re two or three. But your truck isn’t. I’m not saying hey you have to go out and buy a new truck or whatever. But I’ll tell you what one thing that you could do is freshen it up as best you can, slap a coat of paint on it, make it look presentable.

We have some vehicles that my fleet of trucks is basically like 2012. They all look the same in a sense. They’re not the newest trucks. It’s 2026 right now. I’m starting to realize that these trucks are getting older. They’re 14 years old. I buy them with low mileage and they’re used and everything. But the thing is it’s not they’re the brand newest thing, but they’re clean. They don’t have a ton of rust or anything on them.

I had one of them repainted just because it was starting to get kind of dinged up and everything. So I’m like it doesn’t have to be perfect but at least let’s paint it real quick. I didn’t have the body work done to get all the dents taken out of it either. But just having a fresh coat of paint on it looks sharp. You got the logos and everything on it. Maybe that’s something that you don’t have yet. But I’ll tell you what happens when you pull up in a truck that’s plain Jane versus a truck that has the logo and everything on it.

It puts a different perspective into people’s minds, not just your clients, but their neighbors.

 

Ezra McCarthy

Gotta jump in here and say please don’t put magnet stickers on. That in my opinion is almost worse than nothing. To me it just screams janky.

 

John Pajak

Depending on now I’ve seen the janky ones, but I have also seen some pretty decent ones. So I guess it’s a matter of how you execute on it. Because I’ll tell you what there are some towns that I live by that we used to service but we don’t service anymore and the town requires you to have something to identify you.

 

Ezra McCarthy

I’ve never heard of that.

 

John Pajak

Highland Indiana. They have a requirement with their contractors that you have to identify your vehicle. People don’t always do it. But anyway they’ll slap a magnet on there and you can kind of tell. But yeah if you can. I mean the vinyl lettering is very affordable. And honestly there’s a couple places where you could get it done. Just get the vinyl cut for you.

And then you can install it yourself. It takes some time, but I’d highly recommend getting a professional to do it because if they mess up then they fix it. But if you do it then you’re like.

 

Ezra McCarthy

And if you think putting your iPhone screen on is hard, try this vinyl on.

 

John Pajak

Exactly. The vinyl is. It can be really tricky, especially with your logo. You got to get all the bubbles out of it. If you don’t know what you’re doing you could always learn, but just don’t expect professional results out of it. But yeah. Just showing up professional and looking like you said having really good pictures. I would highly recommend if you can’t, if you’re at the point where you’re still not going to get a professional photographer for a day to take pictures and take the glamour shots for you, your phone.

It is an amazing camera. Most people have a relatively new Android or Apple phone and those cameras on those things are ridiculously good. So you don’t necessarily have to go out and buy your own Nikon camera. You could take really high quality photos with your own phone. Again it makes life easier when you hire a professional. It’s the same thing with what we do. A lot of clients just even lawn mowing.

They spend all day trying to get their lawn looking great and they can’t get the line straight or they can’t quite trim it the way we do it. And we walk through it, breeze through it so easily because it’s what we do every single day and just make it look good. Even guys that I would say aren’t very good at their job can make it look better than most amateurs. If you can try to focus on your image because that actually goes a long way.

 

Ezra McCarthy

This really comes back to branding. I think what people don’t realize is every single part of these facets of business comes back to your brand and how it comes across. Well John I’d like to end with two things here. I’ve been trying to ask people lately. Is there any book that you’ve enjoyed recently and then a good podcast maybe you’ve enjoyed recently as well?

 

John Pajak

Recent podcasts. The Side Hustle Squad with Mike Garvey. That’s been a good one. There’s a whole bunch of people that I know that have great podcasts besides Ezra. The Green Industry Podcast, Paul Jamieson. You’ve got an LCR Media Podcast with Neil or Talia Farrow. Those are all very good resources because it’s not just fluff. We’re trying to actually execute on messaging and really helping people develop their business.

That’s a very unusual thing to see in our space. A lot of people have podcasts and things like that and they think it’s great because they get to talk with their buddies about a lot of stuff. Half the time it’s not even about our lawn care business. And don’t get me wrong it’s fun to listen to that. But if you’re looking for the fundamentals of podcasts that I’ve mentioned before they’re very good. One specifically on sales if you’re trying to up your game. The Deep with Eric Triplett. That is a great podcast to listen to as well.

 

Ezra McCarthy

Now a book. Any books recently you’ve recommended?

 

John Pajak

Man, I read so many books I don’t even know what to look at. I’m literally surrounded by books. Actually you already mentioned Story Brand with Donald Miller. That’s actually. It doesn’t matter what industry you’re in because it’s pretty generic in a sense. But all those are fundamentals when it comes to marketing and getting your story told. Again Donald has a very unique way of presenting it. And instead of thinking of yourself as the hero in the story you really should look at yourself as you’re the Yoda.

You’re the Jedi master that’s going to guide everybody. If you want to put it into other terms you’re Mick. Rocky. Do you guys remember Rocky? Mick was his coach. You’re not Rocky you’re Mick. You have to make sure that your client feels like Rocky. You’re the one that’s just going to guide them. Because when you make it about yourself that’s when you start losing people. I’ve got all these trucks. I’ve got all these people. We have hundreds of lawn clients. Me me me me me me. People tune out with that.

But if you make it about them and their journey and what they need, I’ve used that framework myself with trying to help them when they’re trying to figure out what’s the difference between us and everybody else. Well one we’re really good at what we do. But second, what do you want? What are you looking to accomplish? And they’re not used to answering those questions. They’re just used to getting a price and then okay well when do you start service? When we go through the process, and I think this is why we’ve been so successful, if we talk about them, what their goals are.

It’s just like when I have a coaching client. Somebody comes to me for consulting. I don’t necessarily just start opening up the fire hose and start just spewing out knowledge. I ask them what their goals are because that’s what’s important. When I understand what they want to accomplish then I am the wise old guru. I could just. I hate that word but anyway. I’m that guy that could literally walk with you and show you the things. I’m Mr. Miyagi. I’m the one that’s going to wax on wax off.

You’re like why are we doing this? I’m like trust me you’re going to figure it out later. And then next thing they know they thought they were doing chores in the backyard and then also now they know how to do karate. It’s like they are accomplishing their goals. So yeah to answer your question there were those podcasts and a good read is Story Brand by Donald Miller.

 

Ezra McCarthy

Tremendous book. Well John, someone’s interested in getting into that cohort of the new group you’re starting up, where’s the best place to find you, perhaps find out information there?

 

John Pajak

At johnpajak.com. That is the best. Just go to that website and it will be listed. It’s not always going to be open because once I fill the seats you’re just going to have to wait till the next rotation happens. So if there’s a link available then go ahead and sign up to try to get on the waiting list. I’m actually having approvals for this. It’s not just something you could just buy into. I will be honest there’s a bit of a. It’s not hard but.

We do kind of pre vet people just to make sure that it’s going to be a good fit, not just for them but for us as well. Because there’s been times when people want to get in on it and they’re not quite ready. And I hate to say it that way but it’s just like you need a little bit more skin in the game. You need to experience business a little bit more. And I do have consulting just for that if you’re starting out. But again we’re looking to help owners that are.

Doing about 150K to 800,000 somewhere in that neighborhood because that’s where the messy middle is and a lot of guys get stuck in that time. So that’s where we’re trying to appeal to and trying to help at this point.

 

Ezra McCarthy

Well John it’s been great to chat with you and no doubt the listener has gotten value. Thank you each one for tuning in. Be sure to hit that follow button if you haven’t, top right hand corner or wherever you’re listening and we’ll catch you on the next one.

Boost Your Results with Our SEO Checklist

Subscribe

* indicates required